Beyond Carat vs Clean Origin
One of the original lab-grown pioneers — now owned by Grown Brilliance — versus a made-to-order NYC Diamond District studio. Here is an honest side-by-side.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Clean Origin if a long return window is your priority — 60 days is twice the industry standard — or you want to browse ~24,000 loose stones at genuinely low prices and don't mind a virtual-only experience.
Choose Beyond Carat if you want a made-to-order ring from the NYC Diamond District with express production options (as fast as 7 days or next day), configure-your-own grades with live pricing, and an in-person option in New York.
Entry pricing is comparable at both. Both back their jewelry with a lifetime manufacturing warranty and free insured shipping.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Category | Beyond Carat | Clean Origin |
|---|---|---|
| 1 ct lab diamond solitaire ring | From ~$1,049 | From ~$1,000; typically $1,300–$1,800 |
| Diamond types | Lab-grown only | Lab-grown + natural (added after 2024 acquisition) |
| Ownership | Independent, women-led | Owned by Grown Brilliance since Aug 2024 |
| Certification | IGI, included with your order | IGI or GCAL (0.50 ct+) |
| Selection model | Made to order — configure carat, color, clarity, metal with live pricing | ~24,000 loose stones + ~190 setting styles |
| Production / delivery | Regular ~15 days, Express ~7 days, Next-Day option on select pieces | Typically 1–3 business days delivery on ready items; no express custom option |
| Shipping | Free insured UPS 2nd Day Air (US), signature required | Free insured FedEx both ways, discreet packaging |
| Returns | 30 days from ship date, free prepaid label (US); custom pieces → store credit | 60 days; exchanged/resized/engraved items final sale; custom → store credit; $100 missing-certificate fee |
| Resizing | One free resize within 30 days (US) | One free resize within 60 days (standard styles) |
| Warranty | Lifetime manufacturing warranty + free cleaning | Lifetime manufacturing warranty; paid Forever Service Plan for more |
| Physical presence | NYC Diamond District studio (62 W 47th St) | None — virtual appointments only |
Competitor details gathered from public Clean Origin pages and independent reviews, checked July 2026. Beyond Carat is not affiliated with Clean Origin. Spot something outdated? Tell us and we'll fix it.
Category by Category
Pricing
Credit where due: Clean Origin's loose-stone prices are genuinely low — a 1-carat D/VS1 excellent-cut round can list under $500. With solitaire settings from about $525, complete 1-carat rings start around $1,000 and typically land between $1,300 and $1,800 as grades and settings step up.
Beyond Carat's complete 1-carat solitaires start around $1,049, with the customizer showing exactly what each carat, color, clarity, and metal choice costs. At entry level the two brands are close; the difference is in what you're buying — Clean Origin pairs a warehouse stone with a catalog setting, while Beyond Carat cuts, sets, and finishes your ring to order in New York.
Bottom line: pricing is roughly a tie at matching grades. Decide on experience, speed, and service instead.
Returns & Resizing — Clean Origin's Best Card, With Fine Print
Clean Origin built its reputation on a 100-day return window. That policy is gone: as of 2026 the window is 60 days. To be fair, 60 days is still double the 30-day industry standard (including ours), and its free resize window is also 60 days versus our 30. If maximum decision time matters to you, Clean Origin wins this category.
Read the conditions, though: exchanged, resized, or engraved items become final sale, custom orders refund as store credit, a missing certificate costs $100, and returns need an authorization code — without one, a $150 restocking fee can apply. Beyond Carat's 30-day policy is simpler: free prepaid UPS label, refund in 5–7 business days after inspection, store credit for custom-configured pieces.
Bottom line: Clean Origin offers more time; Beyond Carat offers a simpler process. Neither gives cash refunds on fully custom work.
Brand Stability & Experience
Clean Origin was one of the first lab-grown-only retailers, but the company behind the brand hit financial distress and was acquired by Grown Brilliance in August 2024. Since then its showrooms were rebranded as Grown Brilliance locations, the return window shrank from 100 to 60 days, and natural diamonds joined the lineup — so "lab-grown only" no longer applies. None of that makes it a bad place to buy, but if you're choosing Clean Origin specifically as an independent lab-grown pure-play, that identity now belongs to its parent brand's portfolio.
Beyond Carat is an independent, women-led lab-grown specialist operating from the NYC Diamond District, where you can visit in person — Clean Origin is virtual-only.
Bottom line: know who you're actually buying from; Clean Origin is a Grown Brilliance brand now.
Speed & Certification
Clean Origin delivers ready items quickly — typically within a few business days — but offers no express option for made-to-order work. Beyond Carat lets you pick production speed: Regular (~15 days), Express (~7 days), or Next-Day on select pieces ordered before 2:45 PM ET. On paperwork, Clean Origin stones carry IGI or GCAL reports (0.50 ct and up); every Beyond Carat diamond ships with its IGI report in the box.
Bottom line: ready-to-ship favors Clean Origin; anything custom on a deadline favors Beyond Carat.
Who Each Brand Is Best For
Beyond Carat is best for you if…
- You want a ring made to your exact spec, not picked from a warehouse
- You're on a timeline — express (~7 day) and next-day production options
- You want an in-person option in NYC's Diamond District
- You value buying from an independent, women-led specialist
- You want live, transparent pricing as you configure grades
Clean Origin is best for you if…
- You want the longest practical return window — 60 days
- You want a 60-day free resize window
- You're happy browsing loose stones at aggressive prices
- You're fine with a fully virtual experience
- You may still want to compare natural diamonds in one place
Frequently Asked Questions
Entry pricing is comparable — Beyond Carat complete 1-carat solitaires from ~$1,049, Clean Origin from ~$1,000 and typically $1,300–$1,800 as grades step up. Clean Origin's loose stones are genuinely inexpensive. Always compare complete rings at matching certified grades.
No — the window is now 60 days (still double the industry standard). Exchanged, resized, or engraved items are final sale, custom orders get store credit, and a missing certificate costs $100. Many older review sites still quote 100 days; the live policy says 60.
No. Since being acquired by Grown Brilliance in August 2024, Clean Origin also sells natural diamonds. Beyond Carat remains a lab-grown-only specialist.
Ready-to-ship items from Clean Origin arrive within a few business days. For made-to-order rings, Beyond Carat is the one offering speed control — Regular ~15 days, Express ~7 days, Next-Day on select pieces.
Clean Origin is virtual-only — its former showrooms became Grown Brilliance locations after the acquisition. Beyond Carat welcomes you at 62 W 47th St in the NYC Diamond District, and offers free video and phone consultations everywhere else.
Made to Order, Made in New York
Configure a certified lab-grown diamond ring with transparent, real-time pricing — with express production when you need it fast.
More comparisons: vs Brilliant Earth · vs Grown Brilliance · Clean Origin Alternatives · Why Beyond Carat